A project is expected to save 60,000 a year for three years against a one-off cost of 100,000. The simple cost-benefit judgement is that the project:
- Ais rejected because the payback period exceeds one year
- Bis at break-even only, since benefits barely cover the cost
- Cis justified, as benefits of 180,000 exceed the 100,000 cost
- Dis justified only if it also reduces headcount
Total benefit (3 x 60,000 = 180,000) exceeds the 100,000 cost, so on a simple cost-benefit basis the project is justified.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- C (correct). 180,000 in benefit against 100,000 cost is favourable.
- A. Payback is under two years and total benefit exceeds cost, so rejection is wrong.
- B. A $180,000 benefit against a $100,000 cost is well above break-even.
- D. Headcount reduction is not required; the benefit already exceeds the cost.
Reference: ASQ CSSBB BoK - II.C.2 Financial measures.