A project's payback is 20 months and it has a two-year benefit life. A rival project pays back in 26 months and has a seven-year benefit life. A board rule says to approve payback under 24 months. What is the BEST decision approach?
- AApprove the first project and reject the second, since just the first meets the board's payback rule
- BCompare discounted value over each project's life, using payback as one input and not the decision rule
- CApprove the second project, since a longer benefit life leads to a higher value, and the rival project's later payback matters less than the number of years of benefit
- DReject both, since payback of over 18 months is generally considered poor investment practice
Payback ignores the time value of money and benefits after payback, so whole-life discounted value should drive the decision.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- B (correct). Whole-life discounted value shows which project adds more, with payback only one input.
- A. The rule ignores benefits after payback, which favour the second project.
- C. A longer life does not guarantee more value without comparing costs and timing.
- D. A general threshold without calculation rejects investments without testing their value.
Reference: ISACA CGEIT Job Practice, Domain 3: Benefits Realization