Under board policy introduced after a reputational incident, a procurement team updating a chemical supply specification must include environmental and ethical sourcing requirements alongside technical criteria. The team, recognising that these requirements have implications for both the types of purchase and supplier qualification, debates where these should sit. Where should these requirements be documented?
- AThe scope section, which defines the products and suppliers to which the specification applies, including any restricted sources.
- BEnvironmental, social and governance criteria section.
- CThe testing and acceptance section, which verifies supplier compliance against all stated requirements at the point of delivery.
- DThe description of requirements, because all technical and non-technical criteria should be consolidated into one comprehensive section.
Specifications include a dedicated ESG section for environmental criteria (emissions, waste, resource use), social requirements (labour standards, ethical sourcing), and governance considerations. Embedding ESG in the description of requirements or scope reduces visibility and accountability. A standalone section allows ESG compliance to be tracked, audited, and updated independently.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- B (correct). A dedicated ESG criteria section captures environmental, social and governance requirements separately so compliance can be tracked, audited and updated independently.
- A. Scope defines applicability and which products the specification covers - not the dedicated home for environmental and ethical sourcing requirements.
- C. Testing and acceptance verifies compliance at delivery - it does not itself contain the ESG requirements, which need their own dedicated section.
- D. Embedding ESG in the description of requirements reduces visibility and accountability; a standalone ESG section is the recommended approach.
Reference: CIPS L4M2, LO3, AC 3.2.6: Environmental, social and governance criteria