A procurement manager is facilitating a dispute between an internal IT stakeholder and an external software development supplier. The IT team claims the supplier has not delivered against agreed requirements; the supplier disputes the requirements as unclear from the outset. The procurement manager wants to apply Thomas-Kilmann's conflict-handling framework to choose an appropriate mode. Which of the following correctly identifies the FIVE conflict modes in Thomas-Kilmann's model?
- AForming, Storming, Norming, Performing, Adjourning - the stages.
- BPower, Role, Task, Person, Hybrid.
- CUnfreeze, Change, Refreeze, Re-evaluate, Reinforce.
- DCompeting, Collaborating, Compromising, Accommodating, Avoiding.
The Thomas-Kilmann instrument maps five conflict-handling modes on two axes - assertiveness (pursuit of own concerns) and cooperativeness (pursuit of others' concerns). Competing is high-assertive/low-cooperative; Collaborating is high on both; Compromising is mid on both; Accommodating is low-assertive/high-cooperative; Avoiding is low on both. Selection depends on the importance of the issue, the importance of the relationship, and urgency.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- D (correct). Thomas-Kilmann's five modes - Competing (assertive, uncooperative); Collaborating (assertive AND cooperative - win-win); Compromising (mid on both); Accommodating (unassertive, cooperative); Avoiding (low on both).
- A. These are Tuckman's team-development stages, not Thomas-Kilmann's conflict modes.
- B. Power/Role/Task/Person are Handy's four organisational cultures (no "Hybrid" category). Not conflict modes.
- C. Unfreeze/Change/Refreeze is Lewin's three-stage change model (and not five stages); not a conflict-handling framework.
Reference: CIPS L4M6, LO2, AC 2.2.3: Identify sources of conflict and methods to manage conflict successfully