At a telecommunications firm, a senior procurement manager is evaluating the probability and potential impact of a key supplier's manufacturing facility being affected by seismic activity. Historical data shows three significant earthquakes in the region over the past fifty years. The facility produces components worth £8 million annually. Which calculation best represents the annualised value at risk (probability multiplied by monetary effect)?
- A£8 million multiplied by 50 years, giving a total of £400 million over the planning horizon.
- B£8 million divided by three events to give a per-event cost of approximately £2.67 million.
- CAn annual probability of 0.06 multiplied by the £8 million impact to give an annual value at risk of £480,000.
- DThe value at risk is zero because earthquakes are rare and should not be included in a procurement risk register.
Value at risk combines the probability of risk events with their monetary effect. It is calculated by multiplying the annual probability by the impact - with 3 events in 50 years giving an annual probability of 0.06, this gives 0.06 * £8 million = £480,000 per year. Gross 50-year totals, per-event division, and treating rare events as zero all misapply the method.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- C (correct). An annual probability of 0.06 multiplied by the £8 million impact gives a value at risk of £480,000 per year.
- A. This multiplies the exposure by the number of years rather than by the annual probability. Value at risk requires multiplying the impact by the probability of occurrence, not the time period.
- B. Dividing exposure by the number of historical events does not produce a value at risk. The correct approach is to multiply the annual probability of occurrence by the potential financial impact.
- D. Treating a rare but high-impact event as a zero value at risk is wrong: value at risk multiplies the annual probability by the impact (0.06 x £8 million = £480,000), so the risk must be included in the register.
Reference: CIPS L5M2, LO 3, AC 3.1.1: Methodologies for assessing the probability and impact of risk