A measure of hand-hygiene compliance is highly reproducible between observers but the definition counts a quick glove change as compliance, which most experts would not accept. Which property does the measure have, and which does it lack?
- AIt is reliable but not valid
- BIt is valid but not reliable
- CIt is both reliable and valid
- DIt is neither reliable nor valid
A measure that is reproducible but captures the wrong thing is reliable but not valid.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- A (correct). Consistent results between observers make it reliable, but counting the wrong thing means it is not valid.
- B. It is reproducible, so it is reliable; the flaw is that it does not measure the intended concept.
- C. Measuring the wrong thing means it is not valid, so it is not both.
- D. It is reproducible, so it is at least reliable.
Reference: NAHQ CPHQ 2024 Content Outline - Domain 4 Health Data Analytics.