Two clients each expect the Garnet Index to rise. Anselm pays a $4 premium for a call option on one unit of the index with a $100 strike. Brielle takes the long side of a futures contract on one unit of the index at $100. At expiration the index settles at $80. Ignoring commissions and margin costs, what is each client's result per unit?
- AAnselm loses $20 and Brielle loses $4, because the option holder is obligated to complete the trade at the strike price
- BAnselm loses $4 and Brielle loses $20
- CAnselm loses $24 and Brielle loses $20, because Anselm must exercise the call and also forfeits the premium he paid
- DAnselm loses $20 and Brielle loses $20, because both positions are tied to the same $100 price and fall in value with the index
A call buyer has a right, not an obligation: with the index at $80 and the strike at $100 he lets the option expire and loses only the $4 premium. A futures buyer is obligated to settle at the contract price, so a fall from $100 to $80 costs $20 per unit. That asymmetry is the core difference between an option and a futures contract.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- B (correct). The option buyer may let the call lapse and lose only the premium, while the futures buyer must settle at $80 against the $100 contract price.
- A. The roles are reversed: the call buyer holds a right and can walk away, while the futures buyer holds the obligation and bears the full $20 decline.
- C. Anselm has no duty to exercise an out-of-the-money call, so he lets it expire and loses only the $4 premium.
- D. An option buyer's loss is capped at the premium because he is not required to exercise, so his result differs from the futures buyer's.
Reference: NASAA Series 65 Content Outline, Area 2: Investment Vehicle Characteristics (sub-topic 2.G)