An employer decides not to fit an inexpensive, simple guard to a dangerous machine, arguing it is 'not worth the bother'. In terms of reasonably practicable, why is this likely to be unacceptable?
- AReasonably practicable has no bearing on machine guarding
- BThe small cost and effort would be grossly disproportionate to this minor risk
- CThe small cost and effort are not grossly disproportionate to the serious risk
- DThe law requires every risk to be removed at any cost
Under the reasonably practicable test, the sacrifice (a low-cost, simple guard) is weighed against the risk (serious injury from a dangerous machine). Where the cost is small and the risk serious, the control is clearly reasonably practicable and must be provided.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- C (correct). A cheap, easy control against a serious risk must be done.
- A. Reasonably practicable applies directly to guarding decisions.
- B. The risk here is serious, so the small cost is not disproportionate and the guard is reasonably practicable.
- D. The standard is reasonably practicable, not elimination at any cost.
Reference: NEBOSH HSW Award, Element 1 (reasonably practicable).