An auditor lists two control deficiencies. In one, the signature of the petty cash checker is missing for two months of a £200 float. In the other, manual journals posted by the finance director are not reviewed by anyone, and there is no limit on their value. Which is more likely to be significant, and why?
- ABoth are equally significant, because every deficiency in control has to be reported to the board in the same way
- BThe petty cash signatures, because they show a failure in a control that is carried out every month
- CThe unreviewed journals, because they could allow a material misstatement to go undetected
- DNeither is significant, because deficiencies matter when a misstatement has actually been found in the accounts
A deficiency is significant where it could allow a material misstatement to go undetected. Unreviewed, unlimited journals by the finance director carry that risk.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- C (correct). A significant deficiency is one that could allow a material misstatement to be neither prevented nor detected.
- A. The auditor judges the significance of each deficiency by its potential effect, and they do not carry equal weight.
- B. The float is small, so the missing signatures are unlikely to lead to a material misstatement.
- D. A deficiency can be significant by its potential for misstatement, even before any error has been found.
Reference: control deficiencies.