A galvanizing plant must control a fume hazard and lists four options: respirators, a fume-extraction hood, a work instruction, and switching to a lower-fuming process. Ranked by Clause 8.1.2 from most to least preferred, which order is correct?
- ARespirators, work instruction, fume-extraction hood, then switching to the lower-fuming process
- BSwitch to a lower-fuming process, fume-extraction hood, work instruction, then respirators
- CFume-extraction hood, respirators, process switch, then the work instruction
- DWork instruction, fume-extraction hood, respirators, then the process switch
Clause 8.1.2 ranks controls: switching to a lower-fuming process is substitution (highest here), the fume-extraction hood is an engineering control, the work instruction is administrative, and respirators are PPE, the last resort.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- B (correct). Substitution, engineering, administrative, then PPE.
- A. This reverses the hierarchy; substitution and engineering controls outrank administrative controls and PPE.
- C. Switching the process (substitution) ranks above the extraction hood (engineering).
- D. The process switch (substitution) is highest, and the work instruction is administrative, near the bottom.
Reference: ISO 45001:2018, Clause 8.1.2 Eliminating hazards and reducing OH&S risks.