A city transport programme finds its SIAM integrator cannot get suppliers to meet their commitments, because although it answers for the whole service, it was never granted the power to enforce anything. What lesson does this carry?
- AThe integrator should stay accountable but leave enforcement to each supplier
- BThe integrator role should be dropped so suppliers coordinate directly
- CThe integrator ought to personally carry out every supplier's own delivery work itself
- DAn integrator needs enforcement power that matches what it answers for, or SIAM cannot function
For SIAM to work, the integrator needs authority matching its end-to-end accountability; responsibility without authority is a common failure mode.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- D (correct). Authority must match accountability, or the integrator cannot hold providers to account.
- A. Accountability without matching authority is exactly why this arrangement failed.
- B. Removing the integrator abandons end-to-end coordination rather than fixing the authority gap.
- C. The integrator coordinates rather than performing all delivery.
Reference: CDS syllabus LO3.2c, service integration and management.