A regulated project has fixed scope, a signed contract and strict audit requirements. A stakeholder proposes abandoning the baselines and running it purely adaptively. Why is this usually unwise?
- AAn adaptive team's evolving backlog automatically satisfies all the external audit requirements
- BA signed contract still allows scope to change freely without formal control
- CAdaptive delivery would still track the same baselines, so little would change
- DFixed scope and audit needs suit predictive control against baselines, which abandoning would undermine
Fixed scope, a signed contract and audit needs favour predictive control against baselines; abandoning them would undermine the control the environment requires. Adaptive would not preserve those baselines, a signed contract still needs formal change control, and a backlog alone does not satisfy audit requirements.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- D (correct). Fixed scope and audit needs are what predictive control against baselines is built for.
- A. This assumes a backlog meets audit needs, but audit control relies on the documented baselines being kept.
- B. This ignores change control, but a signed, regulated contract requires formal handling of any change.
- C. This assumes adaptive keeps fixed scope baselines, but it deliberately does not, which is the whole risk.
Reference: CAPM 2023 ECO, Domain II Task 1 (predictive fit reasoning fresh).