A pension scheme used a leveraged liability-driven investment strategy, holding gilts and derivatives to hedge its long-dated liabilities. When gilt yields spiked rapidly, the leverage generated large collateral calls that the scheme struggled to meet without selling assets fast. The broad lesson is that leveraged hedging strategies must be managed with attention to:
- Aliquidity to meet collateral calls under fast, severe market moves
- Bmaximising leverage to hedge as much liability as possible at low cost
- Cthe credit rating of the scheme's own members
- Dthe historical returns earned on the scheme's assets
The lesson is that a leveraged hedge removes one risk (liability rate sensitivity) but creates another (liquidity risk from collateral calls) that must be sized, buffered and stress tested against fast, severe moves, not just gradual ones. Managing leverage and liquidity jointly, with adequate buffers and rapid funding access, keeps a sound hedge from becoming a forced-sale crisis.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- A (correct). Leveraged hedges need liquidity planning for rapid, severe collateral calls.
- B. Maximising leverage enlarges collateral calls and was the source of the vulnerability.
- C. Members' credit ratings are irrelevant to the liquidity risk.
- D. Past asset returns are not the liquidity lesson from the collateral calls.
Reference: PRM Exam 2, Case Study Practicum (VIII).