A manufacturing group's internal audit function has, over two years, drifted so that four fifths of its hours go to consulting on projects, while the group's treasury and revenue-cycle risks have not been assured in that time. What should the chief audit executive do?
- AKeep the current emphasis on consulting, since the volume of project requests is the clearest sign that the function is seen as useful across the group
- BRebuild assurance coverage of treasury and revenue-cycle controls into the plan, and take on consulting work only where it does not crowd out assurance over those key risks
- CMove the function to a consulting-led role and hand the assurance work to the external auditor, since consulting during projects prevents problems before they can arise and is valued by the group
- DAsk project sponsors to submit their consulting requests through a single queue and clear that queue before assurance engagements are scheduled in the plan
Balancing assurance and advisory work means rebuilding coverage of key risks and accepting advisory work only where it does not displace that coverage.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- B (correct). Assurance over the neglected key risks is rebuilt and consulting is accepted only where it does not crowd it out.
- A. High demand for consulting is not evidence of value when key risks sit unassured for two years.
- C. Handing assurance to the external auditor abandons internal audit's own assurance role and overstates prevention over assurance.
- D. A consulting queue still places that work ahead of the neglected assurance, leaving the imbalance in place.
Reference: CIA Part 3, Section A.1 (balancing assurance vs advisory); Global Internal Audit Standards.