A call-centre operator sets performance targets and bonuses with no regard to the risks of hitting them, and agents begin meeting the targets in ways that breach the risk limits. The audit function assesses how far risk is built into performance management. Which read holds up best?
- ATargets and bonuses should be set with their risks in view, since cutting the targets off from risk drives agents to hit them in ways that push past the operator's own appetite
- BPerformance management should be kept wholly apart from risk management, since mixing the two would only pull agents away from their focus on meeting the performance targets that have been set them
- CThe issue is purely a human-resources matter about how the bonuses are designed, sitting with reward policy rather than with how well risk management is built into the running of the operator
- DThe operator should simply do away with all of its performance bonuses, since any bonus scheme is bound in the end to drive agents into breaching the operator's risk limits one way or another
Embedding risk into performance management means setting targets and bonuses with their risks in view so performance is pursued within appetite; targets cut off from risk drive people to breach limits.
Why each option is right or wrong.
- A (correct). Building risk into target-setting and bonuses keeps target-chasing within appetite; cutting them off from risk drives limit breaches.
- B. Keeping performance apart from risk is the cause of the problem, not a sound design principle.
- C. A bonus design that drives risk breaches is squarely a risk-integration issue, not merely an HR matter.
- D. Doing away with all bonuses is disproportionate; the fix is to align bonuses with risk, not abolish them.
Reference: CRMA Syllabus S2.B.1 (integration into performance management); COSO ERM (2017) Performance.